Sarah Otwell, Nurse Practitioner

Sarah Otwell

Nurse Practitioner

90 Sylvan Parkway
Amherst, NY 14228

Overall rating

4.97

Top reviews

As someone who went through A LOT of providers before getting connected with Sarah, I can attest that she’s extremely valuable to the mental health field. She treats you as a person, not just a patient number in the filing cabineShow moret. I have always had a great experience and I’ll be going on almost 2 years under her care. She is hands down the provider to help if that’s what you’ve been looking for and struggling to find.

Rachel S • June 10, 2026

Sarah is one of an increasingly small pool of providers who takes the time to connect with you, listen to you, and validate your experience. I go out of network to see her, because she's worth it. I highly recommend her.

Dawn M • March 25, 2026

Read more reviews

Got questions for
Sarah Otwell?


Services, Conditions and Procedures

Depressive Disorders

Anxiety Disorders

Bipolar Disorders

Schizophrenic Disorder

Other disorders that fall under these categories


Location

Sarah Otwell, PMHNP

90 Sylvan Parkway
Amherst, NY, 14228


More About Sarah Otwell

Practice

Sarah Otwell, PMHNP

Specialties

  • Nurse Practitioner

Insurance

  • Blue Cross Blue Shield of New York
  • Independent Health

NPI Number

1073956603


Background and Education

Years practicing

13 years

Education

  • University at Buffalo, 2013
  • D'Youville, 2010

Reviews

4.97
43 Reviews

As someone who went through A LOT of providers before getting connected with Sarah, I can attest that she’s extremely valuable to the mental health field. She treats you as a person, not just a patient number in the filing cabinet. I have always had a great experience and I’ll be going on almost 2 years under her care. She is hands down the provider to help if that’s what you’ve been looking for and struggling to find.

Rachel S • June 10, 2026

She's kind, she listens well to manage your medication and send positive advice

Debbie S • June 10, 2026

Met with Sarah for the first time today, her space is very charming and cozy, Sarah herself as a professional…is very professional, very kind, very patient. Thanks again, Sarah!

John L • June 03, 2026

Sarah is patient and thorough. She tracks what I report and makes thoughtful decisions about her treatment recommendations. I am very comfortable discussing all of my concerns with her.

Jennifer D • May 27, 2026

I feel GREAT! 😊

Sara M • May 27, 2026

Amazing and very attentive. She’s been extremely helpful with my issues. I would recommend her to anyone.

Lucas B • May 15, 2026

Sarah is one of an increasingly small pool of providers who takes the time to connect with you, listen to you, and validate your experience. I go out of network to see her, because she's worth it. I highly recommend her.

Dawn M • March 25, 2026

I have been with Sarah for almost a decade now. She listens and I always feel heard. Caring, empathetic, and supportive. She gives great advice, and I have recommended her to friends and family.

Paul G • March 09, 2026

Sarah and her secretary are lovely humans and Sarah is a great mental health provider. Very caring and knowledgeable. :)

Emily L • March 05, 2026

Sarah is very knowledgeable and personable which makes visits very comfortable. She’s helped me through the most difficult year of my life . I highly recommend.

Alicia L • March 05, 2026

Sarah is so easy to talk to, super understanding, and extremely intelligent. She has helped me navigate different avenues with different medicines to help my mental health. I wouldn't see anyone else.

Saralynn H • March 02, 2026

Sarah was professional, kind, understanding and extremely helpful. I could ask for a better healthcare provider.

Philip B • February 25, 2026

Very attentive and helpful, would recommend to anyone.

Lucas B • February 18, 2026

Sarah is extremely knowledgeable and is very kind and compassionate. I highly recommend Sarah.

James L • January 29, 2026

Sarah is thoughtful and takes her time with me. She covers my mental state, medications, and issues, concerns, questions and always lets me talk. I have recommend her to many family and friends. Most importantly she CARES.

Tracey G • January 28, 2026

Sarah is always excellent to sit down with and truly cares about her patients. Would highly recommend.

Nathan R • January 08, 2026

Sarah Otwell is great, she takes the time to listen and understand me. She is extremely knowledgeable in her field. She is very relatable and makes me feel like I am talking to a friend and not doctor. I would highly recommend her to anyone in need of psychiatry.

Daniel B • December 31, 2025

Dr Otwell is very attentive and thorough. She takes the time to ask all the right questions to ensure you’re feeling and functioning well. Mental health is important and I recommend taking the time to see her.

Debra D • December 19, 2025

After struggling with my mental health for 2.5 years after having my son I felt so lost, until I discovered this practice. I worked with Julie for a few months before she referred me to Sarah to get on some medication these two woman have given me my life back. I finally feel like myself again and I can’t thank them enough. They pulled me out of a very dark place and I will be forever grateful for them

Mara G • December 10, 2025

Genuinely cares about your concerns and addresses your individual needs. Very receptive and knowledgeable about mental health needs.

Ashlie B • December 05, 2025

Sarah is wonderful to work with and I highly recommend her.

Katie W • December 02, 2025

Kind, understanding, supportive.

Pauline K • December 02, 2025

Sarah is very knowledgeable and also extremely caring. She truly cares about her clients. I highly recommend her.

James L • November 22, 2025

Sarah is very personable and makes you feel very comfortable and cared about. Definitely recommend

Alicia L • November 03, 2025

Sarah and the entire team were very kind, respectful and supportive from the beginning. The office is very warm and inviting. Looking for a provider who understands the patient experience, this is your sign.

Jacqueline C • November 01, 2025

I appreciate the time and actual listening Sarah does when I have an appointment. She is thorough and appears to really care. I have recommended her to a few people.

Tracey G • October 30, 2025

Sarah Otwell is in my view the best in her field. Sarah is extremely kind caring and compassionate. Sarah can be extremely helpful but you have to be honest with her about everything going on so she can truly help you.

James L • October 15, 2025

Sarah is attentive, responsive and collaborates well with her clients and parents. We have been working with her for several years and appreciate her professionalism.

Charlotte N • October 08, 2025

Sarah Otwell is an amazing psychiatrist. I've been to dozens over the years and no one has ever taken the time to really know and help me like Sarah has. My mental health is so much better and well supported now than it has ever been in my life. I could not say enough positive things about her or her practice.

Jacob W • October 07, 2025

Sarah is very knowledgeable and understanding. She has been a huge help to me and my mental health.

Philip B • October 01, 2025

View more reviews

Are you Sarah Otwell?

Manage your profile to get more exposure and incoming appointments.