The Intake

Insights for those starting, managing, and growing independent healthcare practices

Claim rejections checklist for medical billing companies

Medical billers can use this checklist to identify and correct common errors prior to submitting claims.

claim rejections checklist for billers

The health of your business relies on how quickly you can get your clients paid. Claim rejections are one of the most significant areas that will slow you down — they can interfere with cash flow and increase administrative burden. Fortunately, billing companies can take proactive steps to avoid rejections and prevent them from derailing operations and impacting revenue streams. 

Many claims are rejected unnecessarily due to input errors. Using a systematic approach lets medical billers identify and correct common errors prior to submission. A comprehensive checklist can catch mistakes at all data entry points before they can cause processing difficulties that lead to payment delays and claim denials.   

We’ve compiled the following checklist to help you prevent rejections and ensure that your practices are set up for success.

Download the workbook

Practice-related rejections 

Practice-related errors usually occur due to incomplete or improperly formatted information, such as missing National Provider Identifiers (NPIs) or mistakes in address transcription. This checklist ensures practice details are correct and optimized. 

Review practice settings 

  • Practice name is no more than 35 characters long 
  • Group NPI is populated, if necessary 
  • Employer identification number (EIN) is populated, if necessary 
  • Practice address contains 9-digit zip code 

Check service location settings 

  • Address contains 9-digit zip code 
  • Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) populated, if necessary

Provider-related rejections 

Inaccurate provider information can result in immediate claim denials, so it’s essential to comply with payer guidelines. Use this checklist to verify provider information and credentials. 

Review provider settings 

  • Individual NPI is populated 
  • Social security number (SSN) is populated, if necessary 
  • Taxonomy is populated 
  • Address(es) contain(s) 9-digit zip code
  • Overrides are created for billing exceptions

Patient-related rejections 

Mismatches in patient information frequently lead to claim issues. A thorough review of the patient profile before submitting claims can prevent mistakes in demographic or insurance details. This section helps you review and verify the accuracy of patient data.

Examine patient profile 

  • Verify patient name 
  • Address contains 9-digit zip code 
  • Eligibility verifications performed 
  • Copies obtained of patient insurance and identification cards 
  • Insured’s policy information is complete, if insured is other than self

Insurance-related rejections 

Rejections often occur due to incorrect payer IDs or incomplete plan information. Use this list to double-check all insurance specifics to avoid common errors.

Inspect insurance companies and plan 

  • Verify payer’s electronic ID 
  • Plan address contains 9-digit zip code

For further assistance with insurance-related challenges, including additional checklists and helpful worksheets, explore our resources for medical billing companies and practices.

Encounter-related rejections

Carefully reviewing encounters before submitting claims ensures the data is complete and correct. This checklist covers the validation of encounter-related information.

View new or edited encounters

  • Verify patient demographics are complete
  • Verify patient eligibility
  • Populate authorization, if necessary
  • Enter Nursing Outcomes Classification (NOC) descriptions, if billing NOC codes
  • Verify service dates
  • Validate procedure and diagnoses codes
  • Verify submit reason

Payment-related rejections

Payment-related errors can delay the final stages of the billing cycle. This section helps to catch and resolve payment-related discrepancies and expedite reimbursement.

View new or edited payments

  • Populate adjudication date
  • Payer populated under simple explanation of benefits (EOB)
  • Validate simple EOB data fields
    • Allowed + adjustments = charges
    • Paid + coinsurance + copay + deductible = allowed

Take control of your revenue cycle

Staying ahead of claims rejections minimizes errors that slow down payments. Optimizing revenue cycles builds client trust in your services, which helps foster long-term partnerships that contribute to the stability of your cash flow. Even small improvements, such as increasing attention to detail with checklists, make billing processes more streamlined and reliable — helping independent practices succeed. 

Tebra's all-in-one solution helps medical billing companies and their clients get paid faster with streamlined billing workflows, intelligent automation, and robust revenue and clinical reporting tools. To learn more about Tebra’s billing and payment solutions, take a tour or schedule a product demo.

Download the guide
Subscribe to The Intake:
A weekly check-up for your independent practice

Amantha May, freelance healthcare writer

Amantha May is a freelance healthcare writer specializing in health tech, primary care, and health equity. She has written for a large range of clients, including medical equipment manufacturers, large health systems, digital health entrepreneurs, and private practices.

Get expert tips, guides, and valuable insights for your healthcare practice