The importance of adopting a sales mindset as a medical biller

Medical billing companies excel at streamlining revenue cycle management and ensuring timely reimbursements. However, many practices are hesitant to outsource billing services due to budget concerns or a lack of understanding of the benefits. Shifting to a sales-oriented approach helps medical billers clearly articulate the value of their services and position themselves as strategic partners.

Follow these tips to hone your skills as a medical biller and win more business.

These tips can help you build an ideal customer profile (ICP):

Identify key characteristics: Determine the types of practices that would benefit most from your services. Consider factors such as practice size, patient volume, current billing challenges, and financial health.

Align your solutions with their needs: Understand common pain points, such as denied claims or slow reimbursements, and tailor your pitch to show how your services can address these issues effectively.

Example: If a practice struggles with administrative overload, emphasize how your efficient billing processes and technology can reduce their workload and increase collections.

Here is how to craft your value proposition to potential customers.

Focus on differentiation: Highlight what makes your billing company unique. Whether it’s specialized expertise, superior technology, or proven results, make sure your pitch clearly communicates your competitive edge.

Use data to build credibility: Incorporate statistics or success stories to back up your claims. For instance, mention how you helped a client increase collections by 20% through optimized billing practices.

Example pitch: “We have been experts in this specialty for over 15 years and have helped hundreds of practices speed up their revenue cycle — here’s how we can achieve the same for you.”

Role-playing exercises: Practice delivering your pitch with a colleague, focusing on clarity, tone, and handling objections. Write down common objections and prepare thoughtful, value-driven responses. Being prepared reduces the chance of curveballs and can help you steer the conversation back to the value you bring.

Refine your delivery based on feedback and adapt your approach for phone, video, or in-person meetings. Then, decide if you’ll use any supporting materials such as handouts, visual data, or case studies to strengthen your message.

Tebra gives billing companies the tools to systematize workflows and create efficiencies that bring speed to payment, scalable growth, and maximized revenue. Learn more here.

When discussing costs, it’s common to encounter objections related to budget constraints or concerns about value. Use the ARA technique (acknowledge, respond, ask) to effectively address these issues.

Acknowledge: “I understand that budget is a concern.”

Respond: “Our services typically lead to a 10–20% increase in net collections, which offsets the cost.”

Ask: “How would this improvement impact your practice’s financial health?”

Often, the stated objection isn’t the real issue. Ask probing questions to get to the heart of their hesitation. For example, “Can you tell me more about your concerns with switching billing providers? Is there a specific feature you’re worried about losing?”

Presenting compelling financial data can help demonstrate why your services are better than those of your competitors.

Highlight metrics that matter: Showcase your impact using data from current or previous clients. Metrics like increased collection rates, reduced claim errors, or faster reimbursements help illustrate the financial benefits of your services. Prepare financial reports or case studies to visually present the return on investment (ROI) during your pitch.

Break down the costs of in-house billing: Help practices compare the total cost of in-house billing (salaries, software fees, taxes) versus the savings and efficiency gains of outsourcing to your company.

Strengthen your closing strategy with these tips.

Use a clear and confident closing line: A good closing line invites the prospect to take the next step. For instance, you could say, “I’ll send over a summary of the metrics we discussed today — along with a reference from a similar practice. Let’s schedule a follow-up call next week to go over any remaining questions and finalize the details.”

Plan consistent follow-ups: Research shows that it can take up to 7 contacts before a prospect makes a decision. Write a few different email templates or practice what you'd say over the phone. Then set a follow-up schedule that includes value-driven touchpoints — such as sharing new data or case studies that address their concerns. 

Keep your clients engaged and show you’re invested in their long-term success.

Check in regularly: Continue engaging with clients after the deal is closed to maintain strong relationships. Offer personalized solutions and proactively address any emerging challenges.

Provide additional services: Pay attention to clients’ evolving needs and look for opportunities to offer additional services. By offering these solutions, you’ll drive additional revenue while positioning your billing company as a proactive, strategic partner that continuously delivers value.

There will come a point when your business needs to increase the cost of services. When it’s time to discuss price adjustments with your customers, lead with data. Regularly review your practices’ financial performance and present measurable results that reflect the value of your services. Gather evidence around how your work led to improved collections, faster payments, and overall business growth to gain client buy-in for any cost increase.

Adopting a medical billing sales mentality is not about using aggressive tactics; it’s about understanding client needs and demonstrating the tangible value of your services. By defining your ideal client, refining your pitch, handling objections effectively, and maintaining strong client relationships, medical billing companies can build trust and close more deals.

Visit tebra.com/billing-companies to learn how we give billing companies the tools to achieve scalable growth and deliver financial well-being — for you and your clients.