physician preparing for medicare advantage audits
  • CMS is ramping up Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audits with hundreds of new medical coders.
  • Physicians may face more record requests, payment recoupments, and legal risks from audits.
  • Use MEAT criteria documentation and staff training to prepare for increased audit scrutiny.

With the recent announcement that CMS plans to ramp up its Medicare Advantage Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV) audits by hiring hundreds of medical coders to determine whether medical records support risk adjustment diagnoses, many providers are left wondering: Will this affect me directly? 

The short answer is this: Possibly. 

Increased Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audits will likely result in more administrative work and financial risks for physicians, especially those with a large Medicare Advantage patient base. Following are 3 possible scenarios that could occur commensurate with CMS’ renewed focus on Medicare Advantage — and how physicians can prepare.

Tebra's medical billing software helps you reduce denials, improve collections, and get paid faster.

1. More frequent requests for medical records 

As CMS begins to increase Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audits to address an ongoing audit backlog, providers may start to notice an uptick in medical record requests. There may also be stricter expectations for clinical documentation of risk-adjusted diagnoses given the propensity for error that the OIG found. 

How to prepare: Talk with your staff now about who will gather, review, and submit records in response to Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audits and payer requests. Designate a point person to manage communication with Medicare Advantage plans and oversee physician risk adjustment in healthcare.

2. Potential recoupments if medical records don’t support risk-adjusted diagnoses

As CMS scrutinizes Medicare Advantage plans, those plans could, in turn, recoup payments from providers who submit codes that are not justified.

How to prepare: Apply the MEAT criteria when documenting. The acronym ‘‘MEAT” stands for monitor, evaluate, assess/address, and treat. Using this strategy ensures clinical documentation supports the assignment of all diagnoses, including those that contribute to risk-adjusted payments. 

In addition, provide ongoing training for coders, billers, and clinicians on: 

  • Physician risk adjustment in healthcare
  • ICD-10-CM coding
  • Risk adjustment documentation
  • Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audit response procedures 

As Dr. Soma Mandal, MD, internal medicine specialist, explains, “As CMS ramps up Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audits, physicians face growing pressure to ensure documentation aligns with coding. Unsupported diagnoses can lead to payment recoupments, legal exposure, and increased administrative burden — especially for those with a large Medicare Advantage patient base.” 

Unsupported diagnoses can lead to payment recoupments, legal exposure, and increased administrative burden — especially for those with a large Medicare Advantage patient base.
Dr. Soma Mandal, MD, Internal Medicine Specialist

Also, use EHR tools or analytics platforms to flag documentation gaps, coding mismatches, and high-risk areas.

If CMS Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audits uncover patterns of upcoding or unsupported diagnoses, physicians may face investigations for fraud or abuse, especially when there is a history of inflated risk scores. 

How to prepare: Conduct internal and/or external risk adjustment audits to ensure coding aligns with documentation and to monitor trends and areas for improvement. Be mindful of copy and paste documentation tools and other templates that encourage physicians to report risk-adjusted diagnosis codes that do not meet reporting criteria.

For example, physicians should not report past diagnoses that do not affect the patient’s care, treatment, or management at the time of the encounter. Reporting these diagnoses can artificially inflate the patient’s risk score.

Promoting proactive compliance

Looking for more resources on physician risk adjustment in healthcare, and how to prepare for Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audits? Here’s a checklist we’ve created to help you succeed.  

In addition, here’s a RADV rulebook to help you understand the audit process and how it affects your medical practice.

How to beat medical billing challenges
Get valuable resources plus practical worksheets to aid you in your journey toward efficient and effective medical billing.
Get the free workbook

Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audit readiness checklist

Documentation and coding:

  • Conduct internal and/or external coding audits regularly to confirm all diagnosis codes are accurate, supported by documentation, and meet MEAT criteria.
  • Ensure providers document and code chronic conditions at least once per calendar year.

Compliance and legal preparedness:

  • Maintain a compliance plan that addresses Medicare Advantage risk adjustment.
  • Respond to record requests on time and with complete documentation.

Staff training:

  • Provide ongoing training to clinical and coding staff on:
  • ICD-10-CM diagnosis code and guideline updates.
  • Medical necessity.
  • Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audit response procedures.
  • Medicare Advantage risk adjustment documentation.

Communication and follow-up:

  • Designate a point person to manage Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audit-related tasks.
  • Keep a log of all Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audit-related communications with the Medicare Advantage plan.
  • Request feedback or clarification from the Medicare Advantage plan when needed.

Technology and tools:

  • Implement software or dashboards to monitor coding trends and Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audit risk.
  • Use EHR tools to flag incomplete documentation or missing diagnoses.

According to Dr. Mandal, “Now more than ever, physician risk adjustment in healthcare must go beyond compliance; it’s about proactively using MEAT criteria, leveraging EHR tools, and training staff to ensure accurate, defensible coding. By tightening documentation workflows and conducting internal audits, providers can protect revenue and stay ahead of regulatory scrutiny.”

By tightening documentation workflows and conducting internal audits, providers can protect revenue and stay ahead of regulatory scrutiny.
Dr. Soma Mandal, MD, Internal Medicine Specialist

Learn how Tebra's all-in-one EHR system gives you smarter charting, faster billing, and a healthier bottom line. Book a free, personalized demo today.

You Might Also Be Interested In

Stay Ahead with Expert Healthcare & Billing Insights

Get the latest industry updates, financial tips, and expert strategies — delivered straight to your inbox.

Lisa Eramo, freelance healthcare writer

Lisa A. Eramo, BA, MA is a freelance writer specializing in health information management, medical coding, and regulatory topics. She began her healthcare career as a referral specialist for a well-known cancer center. Lisa went on to work for several years at a healthcare publishing company. She regularly contributes to healthcare publications, websites, and blogs, including the AHIMA Journal. Her focus areas are medical coding, and ICD-10 in particular, clinical documentation improvement, and healthcare quality/efficiency.

Reviewed by

Soma Mandal, MD

Dr. Soma Mandal is an ABMS board-certified internal medicine physician. She specializes in women’s health with an active practice in New Jersey. She obtained her MD from New York University School of Medicine, and has been listed on Castle Connolly’s top doctor lists in both New York and New Jersey for several years.

Stay Ahead with Expert Healthcare & Billing Insights

Get the latest industry updates, financial tips, and expert strategies — delivered straight to your inbox.